Tuesday, October 14, 2008
China in future Global Order
Recent surge and development of China has developed a debate centered around rise of East and Pacific Ocean . Leading the world world in 21st century and already 21st Century is being called century of China. In history rise of a new power in world affair is usually associated with conflict and violence. This fear adopts increased proportions when we see it that this time the world powers are riding over power of globalization and information technology instead of mere human resources!China asserts that its rise is peaceful rise and its development is for peace and stability 0of world. As the economic and military power of China rises, USA considers it her major future rival and a country which can challenge and take over USA; there are studies that at 5 times less productivity as to USA in 2020 China can take over USA due to her population.Henry Kissinger visited China in 2007 and first time raised point of rivalry due to change in balance of power. But many experts also assert that due to nuclear weapons old traditional methods of military superiority and its active use are not means to affect change. This reality has been changed by the complex, multilateral and liberal free market economy international order of world. This is expressed by United Nations, Breton Woods Financial Institutions, world Trade Organization and relentless pace and currency of Globalization and information technology revolution.These institutions and free market economy are spearheaded by USA and European values and its historical experiences. Thus in recent Foreign Affairs Magazine there is special portion dedicated to China and in this question of future of Chinese superiority over USA in long term is asserted but it is considered that China will not be able to replace the present international order in its favor drastically and radically. As China is itself beneficiary of this International Order, examples being its economic turnaround si all due to Globalization and joining the international, multilateral systems and also China itself accepts the fact of increase in its prestige after joining WTO.USA should keep on China engaged, integrated and curtailed within the present multilateral international liberal market economy order, and this will favor and support USA. G.John Ikenberry in his article “The Rise of China and the future of the West… Can the Liberal System Survive?” in latest issue of Foreign Affairs Magazine January/February 2008 concludes that “The task now is to make so expensive and so institutionalized that China has no choice but to become a full-fledged member of it. The United States cannot thwart China’s rise, but it can help ensure that China’s power si exercised within the rules and institutions that the United States and its partners have crafted over the last century, rules and institutions that can protect the interests of all states in the more crowded world of the future. The United States’ global position may be weakening, but the international system the United States leads can remain the dominant order of the twenty –first century.”This is the crux of realist school of thought based upon idealistic visions of world order.If behavior of China is seen in last decade then it becomes clear that China is rapidly becoming part of this global international liberal system. Its examples are china’s active support to resolve North Korea Crisis under the ambit of six -party talks, active role in UN peace keeping operations. Increased participation in Security Council related matters in UN( Iraq Issue, Iran Nuclear Issue, Darfur Issue , environmental Issue are case in point)and recently her active and increased participation in war against Global Terrorism. These all are indicators of active involvement and participation of China in liberal system but its limitations are also visible where China’s national interests clash for example Taiwan issue ( recent Taiwanese interest in independence through UN) Tibet and her relationships with states not practicing democracy and also Human Right issues. This process of engagement and integration of China in world order is gradually moving and as per assertions of Chinese they have no plan and desire to counter the international system as this will prove counterproductive to their interests.China’s entry into global arena is under the framework of existing legal .multilateral, consensual and liberal systems of institutions developed by Western powers in 20th century and as main factors of Chinese development are exports and FDI, this anchors China to present system and binds her future with stability of the present system based on International Law which seems to be contrary to present policy of USA’s unilateral pursuance in world affairs since last 8 years. In future global stability and peace hinges upon peaceful integration of China in world liberal systems, and USA’s resolve to strengthen the present institutions. But this will depend upon the changes in US Presidency this year as it will change course of policies of USA administration towards international liberal system and will also affect the USA –China relations ranging from trade friction to military issues.If China’s position is seen in this backdrop of international liberal system then except China’s internal touchy issues China has managed to adjust and adopt its policies to ethos of liberal system in its own way based upon active diplomacy and flexibility and resolve to search middle path… this has been shown in Six Party talks, Darfur Issue, Iran Nuclear Issue and terrorism issues. China has been very active in environmental regime to develop national policy in year 2006 to counter the bad press and environmental impact at home at least at policy level. Although ground realities are not as promising as they should be, but China’s resolve to adjust its legal structure and framework has been impressive. So at policy level in short and middle term China will not challenge its course of integration into world liberal system , but its response to USA security threat after war against Terrorism is finished will not be of accommodation and restraint due to increased economic power and its domestic nationalism and insistence on Chinese characteristics. These tenors of Chinese thinking are visible in development of regional alliances and active diplomacy in Africa , Latin America and Asia. China’s role and increasing sophisticated development of SCO and ASEAN mechanism is an indication in this regard. Recent cyber attacks in year 2007 originating from mainland China on computer systems of Europe and USA are indication of increasing muscle of China.China’s place in international liberal system will be determined by various multiple factors of USA behavior and its attitude and stress on War Against Terrorism and policy of new administration on economic issues with China. China will also be affected by rise of India at global scene and China is poised already to contain the role of India in region. .This is shown by China’s active role in regional trade, economic, military and defense relations with its neighbors like Pakistan. Myanmar, Vietnam, Koreas, Russia, other South East countries and her increased role in Central Asia. This historical rivalry with India can also color China’s perceptions of USA as Chinese already think that USA is not happy with their rise. This can play a major underlying role in future options for China in global affairs.China’s place in liberal system will not be governed by response of USA alone it will also be shaped up by its own choices in response to its increasing power and clout gathered by her not due to any historical legacy or cultural extension but mainly due to her rising economic power coupled with military power which at least in next 50 years will not be more advance than USA and European technology at least at theoretical and research level.Success of liberal system will depend on USA‘s resolve to protect 20th century institutions and shun its unilateral behavior and successful integration of China in this reinvigorated and revitalized systems. China has not come up with any alternative right now , rather she is pursuing to be active part of global institutions like WTO, UN, G-8, IMF, World Bank and other rising regional organizations like SCO, ADB etc. China will certainly change the practical expression of liberal system, but she will not be re writing the bases of those institutions, it will go for first claiming her rightful place in the system and then gradually it will integrate in the international system as an active player due to her size but it will not embark on a drastic effort to re- draw the maps or structures of institutions… it will aim for reform not for revolution. If it opts for revolution, then it will be a disaster of Chinese history of early 20th century repeated at global scale as now China will not shake itself… the dragon will shake the world! The sheer size of this Chinese revolution will be of utmost importance for its neighbors and they will be its immediate recipients as west will feel its indirect shocks especially in economic field. This course will be tumultuous due to internal cultural uniqueness and its inherent inability to excel in newer and innovative ideas at daily life and spiritual and philosophical level also. As the previous revolutions were initiated by Chinese but with foreign ideas of Democracy and Marxism and later adjusted to Chinese characteristics as present market system in china is called Socialist market with Chinese characteristics. This adherence restricts the scope of adoption of idea and it has inherent germs of imperialistic tendencies if taken to its extreme as it happened in case of Japan. In middle term behavior of China towards its place in world system will concern its neighbors in far reaching ways its land neighbors and sea neighbors will be affected in different ways. Regional and global affairs of China will be affected with China’s energy needs as this raw material has become of strategic importance for China and she has already understood its gravity as it is planning to open a new Ministry solely dealing with strategic and practical aspects of energy in its economic and strategic development. This will strategically place China at odds with rising environmental concerns at global level despite China’s readiness to adopt more efficient and sustainable models of energy resources.Liberal system of world will also affect China’s internal political system as increased integration of Chinese system with global liberal institutions running on rule of law and democratic aspiration will impact China also. This impact will be crucial factor in determining the gradual integration of China in world society as till now China has kept its own rules and regulations especially in fields of human rights and political affairs. This is a contradiction as in economic and trade matters China has adjusted rather rapidly and surprisingly without any major demur at domestic front. This inherent contradiction will place pressures on role of China if she adapts to the increased active role in liberal system of world affairs
Sunday, October 12, 2008
Food!
Allah has a lot of blessings for us and food is one of them, and our ability to enjoy good food is the best blessings of Allah.May Allah bless us to keep on enjoying his bounties! Ameen
Friday, October 10, 2008
Desires
In jungle of desires I am lost . or perhaps myself stationing to the ever changing landscape of desires. But reality is I am under grip of desires overshadowing and overtaking me in a frenzy sustained by routine of life.
Routine makes the realities of life seem different and perhaps distorted and awkward, a life of so-called pragmatism but devoid of any essence of dreams or ideals... so is present stage of life.
But when seen from the perspective of evolution of thoughts then I realize that this is not a stale moment of life but it is gradually moving towards its inherent goals, what are those goals? Power accumulation? Wealth ? Altruism? Knowledge of Creator and freedom to dream and resolve to change the realities of personal and other's lives. Yes the last is the hops and may be destination, albeit seeming far away right now!
Routine makes the realities of life seem different and perhaps distorted and awkward, a life of so-called pragmatism but devoid of any essence of dreams or ideals... so is present stage of life.
But when seen from the perspective of evolution of thoughts then I realize that this is not a stale moment of life but it is gradually moving towards its inherent goals, what are those goals? Power accumulation? Wealth ? Altruism? Knowledge of Creator and freedom to dream and resolve to change the realities of personal and other's lives. Yes the last is the hops and may be destination, albeit seeming far away right now!
Friday, October 3, 2008
Loneliness
Some times the crouching tiger like moments of strangeness and loneliness mere pounce upon our senses and they just take on the realities of life and the life seems lonely,alone and in search of intimacy!
Saturday, September 27, 2008
Ideas
Ideas are sharpened on the edges of stones and gravels of time and then soem of them prove to be healers of our confusion and ambiguity and many increase the existing ambiguity and persistent absurdity of life.
The dreams of our life are shattered and taken away from us never to recover again by the sharpness of ideas which were never ours and perhaps can never be ours... but they affect us and make us vulnerable to meaninglessness of our times. This is the most painful reality of present existance humanity, seeking thrills and searching to know itself throug means of confusion!
The dreams of our life are shattered and taken away from us never to recover again by the sharpness of ideas which were never ours and perhaps can never be ours... but they affect us and make us vulnerable to meaninglessness of our times. This is the most painful reality of present existance humanity, seeking thrills and searching to know itself throug means of confusion!
Monday, September 22, 2008
Drops of Loneliness
The night is falling like a sunny day!
Relentless,unstoppable and unleashing its secrets......... of loneliness and pain etched on my soul!
Oh night, how far I can embark on journey of desire unfulfilled and unbridled, oh my heart it aches to be happy and alos not to be happy!
Pain is the reality of days and nights, overshadowing me and turning me into grief and dumbness of pain!
Relentless,unstoppable and unleashing its secrets......... of loneliness and pain etched on my soul!
Oh night, how far I can embark on journey of desire unfulfilled and unbridled, oh my heart it aches to be happy and alos not to be happy!
Pain is the reality of days and nights, overshadowing me and turning me into grief and dumbness of pain!
Thursday, September 18, 2008
Human Rights & Pakistan’s Legal Frame work
Human Rights & Pakistan’s Legal Frame work
The emergence of the post colonial states in thee third world countries was result of long, bitter and lengthy struggles based upon the phenomenon of violence in the shape of Independence struggles and the ensuing Civil Wars in the Colonies.
The phenomenon of the independence in the sub-continent is unique in the respect that there was no wide spread violence between the rulers and the ruled. But the infighting and internecine fighting between their Indians was rampant in the Provinces of Bengal and Punjab.
The struggle of Hindus and Muslims was not violent to that extent as it was observed in the Colonies of Africa and other Asian countries. The process was done through the legal transfer of power from the British Raj to the independent states of India and Pakisatn respectively on 15th and 14th August 1947. The bases of the Pakisatn are deeply immersed in the legal process and the founder of Pakisatn is also a lawyer par excellence! the ethos of Pakistani legal system are the direct progeny of the British Raj in India as the adoption of 1935 Act of India shows as the law of the land as the constitution of the Pakisatn.
The legal environment of the Pakisatn is the most complex and diversified in the post Colonial states. The reason for this is the multiple traditions vying for supremacy and incomplete synchronization. The case study of Pakistan in this response is the pioneer study which aims at understanding and evaluating the legal framework and search for the possible solutions to the wade through the quagmire of the legal jungle in the light of the International Bill of Human Rights.
This research is based upon the paradigm which takes the
a) Formal legal acts, ordinances and the constitutional ideas as embedded in the Pakistani Legal frame work
B) The Informal legal traditions and networks in the shape of Jirgas, Panchayats, and the Sardari-cum-feudal network
C) The religious popular expressions as in the Formal Legal Framework
D) The religion in the informal but expressly prevailing environment
These are explored in the ensuing pages in a separate discussion s based upon the structure and foundation of the legal environment from adoption to its implementation.
They are tackled in a systematic and coherent manner with reference to the International Bill of Human Rights and the attached and fundamental documents and treaties attached to the Human Rights Bill.
The major trends of the legal thought and practical application are dealt separately hereby and discussed;
1. The Colonial Legacy
2. The Authoritarian Law Making
3. The Democratic Law Making / the Parliament
4. The religious orthodoxy
5. The Cultural customs and traditions
1. The Colonial Legacy
As mentioned earlier the carving out of the state of Pakisatn is the result of legal process by the conferment of the right of self Government by the Queen of UK in 1947 through the 3 June Plan.
The adoption of 1935 Indian Act as the law of land in the first meeting of the Constituent Assembly was the turning point of the Pakistan’s legal history. This adoption was to be the temporary arrangement till the new Constitution for the Republic was to be adopted, but the ensuing legal complexities were to linger on till the present day. the adoption was not only at the constitutional level but it was at the lower most level in the form of adoption all the British legal instruments with the change of the Name India with Pakisatn usually.
This resulted in the aberration of the legal system which plagues the legal scenario till now. The purpose of the legal system of the British Empire was to protect and sustain the “Steel Frame “ of the British Raj over the Indians. But this steel frame was to be as it is for the post-colonial society in the form of legal environment. The efforts were never aimed at the liberalization, rationalization and the humanization of the legal system of the Pakisatn in the last 6 decades of post-colonial period of existence. The polity of Pakisatn was to be ambivalent, complex, and mercurial and anti-people as the successive changes in the legal framework showed.
The structural construction of the governing framework in the Colonial era was based on the following assertions;
1. The natives were unable to govern themselves; they needed benign rule of the British to make them capable to run self governments.
2. The pre-colonial legal system and structure was inadequate to adjust to the needs and exigencies of the British system so drastically changed the legal framework and environment of the India.
3. The Mughal System of legal administration was enshrined in the local traditions and the cultural mores of the natives and local p[populace. The new legal system was aimed t introduction of the Anglo-Saxon traditions of legal system in the alien land where the natives were the subject of this undue experimentation. The result was the introduction of an elaborate and bureaucratic structure which was ruthless in detail and prompt in its application.
4. The crime regulation system was completely new to the local environment. The introduction of prisons and the police system was entirely alien to the Indian soil. The introduction of this Police system was a severe blow to the human freedom. The Criminal Procedure Code of 1898 was the Steel Frame of this gigantic experiment to control the native “mischievous behavior”!
5. The local revenue system was changed by the introduction of individualized payment system in the form of currency or the individual payment of land revenue instead of the collective payment system for the villages and the specified area.
6. The introduction of the property of the land to the illegal and new occupants after the Permanent Settlement of 1979 in Bengal by Lord Cornelius.
7. The priority of law and order in the crimes control system instead of dealing them in their real perspective.
8. The complete disregard and participation of the local people in the process of legislation for the natives.
9. The discrimination vis-a-vis the natives and Europeans in the application, implementation of the legal system.
10. The sustained policy of exacerbating the urban rural divide in the country due to political exigencies .The treaties made by the local rulers with the British show this anomaly in its overall brutality and harshness towards local people.
2.The Authoritarian Law Making
The legacy of the authoritarian ism bequeathed by the British was carried on the avid followers of the Colonial Masters. They adopted the legal process of the British in the same spirit to keep their hold intact over the local people. This tradition was strengthened by the Military Dictatorships to prolong its rule. The decade of 1960,s, 1980,s are the most prominent in this regard. The specific characteristics of these are as following;
1. the aim of the regimes is to broaden their hold over the segments of the society through the legal means
2. the overall purpose of the law making is the sanctioning the individualistic and dictatorial tendencies of the Dictator
3. The bureaucratic structure of the state is more active and the colonial legacy of the law making is maintained and nurtured further.
4. The support of the regime is limited to certain sections of the society which makes it prone to creating legal immunities sot the supporters of the regime.
5. The resources of the regime are diverted to the areas and strata of the society which help the regime. For this the inherent contradictions are developed in the legal framework of the country which is biased, manipulated by executive and undermine he liberty of the Judiciary. This is corroborated by the earlier legal history of Pakisatn.
6. A pseudo ideological garb of ideology is woven around the legal framework of the country which creates secretiveness and mystery around the legal environment. The challenges to the legal discussions are dealt under the threat to the ideology of the country which changes with the change in the ruler. (The Ayub Era and Zia Era are the true examples).
7. The structural bias of colonial legal framework is skewed further to control dissent, free idea and difference of opinion under the State security ideology. The introduction of the Article 63 in the Constitution by Zia regime is case in point.
8. The absence of the parliament sans the debate and healthy exchange of the ideas on the proposed laws in the dictatorial regimes which stifles the growth of the respect for the human rights and the freedom of the ideas.
9. The increased legislation further extends, enhances the power of colonial inherited institutions of brutality. this phenomenon results in more abuse and repressive towards masses, instead of relief to the people. ( The fine examples of this are the Huddood and Prohibition Ordinances of Zia regime)
10. The implementing arm of the Government i.e. police and attached institutions are protected and given extra powers which curtail the freedom of the people in a complex and sustained way. ( This becomes more horrible and expressive in the semi-urban and rural areas of the country as there is little awareness and literacy to demand its rights)
11. The economic resources are used as a ploy to patronize the sections of the government which adhere to the policies of the Government . The Export Bonus Voucher Scheme of Ayub era is an example of such state patronage.
The dictatorial regimes stress on the obedience and absolute authority which enhances the powers of the powers of the colonially inherited institutions. the dictatorial regime s face a great dilemma as they take over on the promises of changing the destiny of people against the plundering of resources by the inept and corrupt politicians as asserted by them; but the state apparatus which is structurally flawed contributes to its undoing at the end.
The efforts to create unity and discipline through legal means fail to deliver; rather they encourage the separatist and secessionist tendencies. Its examples are the separation of East Pakisatn, the unrest in 1970,s in Baluchistan, in Sindh in 1980,s. This situation deteriorates further when the alien elements are involved; the case of Wazirastan is prime example of this fact.
3. The Democratic /Parliamentary Law Making
Along with the authoritarian regimes the legal developments in the country are result of the democratic law making through the parliament. The traits of this legislation are as following
1. The structure of the Parliament is the determining factor in adoption of the laws. As the structural constitution of the parliament determines the course of the legislation.
2. The leanings of the ruling party or the group of parties are the leading forces which shape up the law making in the Pakistani system.
3. The real legislation of the democratic governments is also dependent upon the same institutions and the legal structure as inherited at the time of independence from the British elite. Their stress is not on changing or transforming the fundamental structure of the legal dispensation at all. Because they are more concerned ot turn the balance of power in the favor of the elected governments as the legislative history of 1990,s shows. This is the settlement of political question through means of legislation within the available parameters and transforming the question of the power between President and the Prime Minister usually. ( The 13 the amendment ) This limitation of the or the locking in of the political governments reduce the scope of action and range of their power to mere structural control instead of creating true legal change in the lives of the people.
4. The inherent political instability and ambiguity of the legal system inherited from the British is increased by every attempt at the change or modification of the existing laws. This is shown by the legislative establishment of newer courts for settling with the increased violence in the society. The establishment of the Anti-terrorist courts shows the inadequacy of the traditional capacity of the courts and the desire of the politicians to improve the law and order system of the country.
5. The biases of the ruling governments as to its electoral base also affect the legislation which helps to perpetuate the rule of few. This further alienates the masses from the social process of development and progress.
6. The institutional capacity of the units of the systems is inadequate to cope with the demands of the modern Human Rights Perspective. The resulting legislation is ambivalent to the rights of people in the practicality.
7. The political uncertainty attached
Bibliography
1. Holy Quran
2. The Constitution Of Islamic Republic Of Pakisatn
3. The Major Acts
4. The Minor Acts
5. The Making Of Pakistan By Richard Symonds
6. Emergence Of Pakisatn By Chaudhery Muhammad Ali
7. The Manual of Prisons Law
8. The Manual of Land Revenue Laws
9. Human Rights--- A Compilation of International Instruments Volume I & II Published by United Nations 2004
10. Human Development in South Asia Published by Mahbub-ul-Haq Development Center Islamabad. ( Various Reports)
11. World Development Report Published By World Bank ( Various Reports)
12. Constitutional Development in Pakistan By G.W Chaudhery
13. Liberty or Death? By Patrick French
Magazines, Newspapers
1. The Monthly Herald Karachi.
2. The Monthly News line Karachi.
3. Daily Dawn Islamabad. Lahore. Karachi Editions
4. Daily Nation Lahore.
5. Daily News Lahore. Rawalpindi Karachi
6. Daily Times Lahore.
7. Daily Nawa-i- Waqt Lahore / Rawalpindi .
8. Daily Jang Lahore /Islamabad
9. Pakisatn Law Digest P.L.D ( Various Issues)
10. Daily Khabrain Lahore.
Note . This article was written in year 2005 and was submitted to UN Human Rights Council via the course I attended in FSA Islamabad. Basic premises of the article are same and as to changes during the time passed I will write later...Insha Allah!
The emergence of the post colonial states in thee third world countries was result of long, bitter and lengthy struggles based upon the phenomenon of violence in the shape of Independence struggles and the ensuing Civil Wars in the Colonies.
The phenomenon of the independence in the sub-continent is unique in the respect that there was no wide spread violence between the rulers and the ruled. But the infighting and internecine fighting between their Indians was rampant in the Provinces of Bengal and Punjab.
The struggle of Hindus and Muslims was not violent to that extent as it was observed in the Colonies of Africa and other Asian countries. The process was done through the legal transfer of power from the British Raj to the independent states of India and Pakisatn respectively on 15th and 14th August 1947. The bases of the Pakisatn are deeply immersed in the legal process and the founder of Pakisatn is also a lawyer par excellence! the ethos of Pakistani legal system are the direct progeny of the British Raj in India as the adoption of 1935 Act of India shows as the law of the land as the constitution of the Pakisatn.
The legal environment of the Pakisatn is the most complex and diversified in the post Colonial states. The reason for this is the multiple traditions vying for supremacy and incomplete synchronization. The case study of Pakistan in this response is the pioneer study which aims at understanding and evaluating the legal framework and search for the possible solutions to the wade through the quagmire of the legal jungle in the light of the International Bill of Human Rights.
This research is based upon the paradigm which takes the
a) Formal legal acts, ordinances and the constitutional ideas as embedded in the Pakistani Legal frame work
B) The Informal legal traditions and networks in the shape of Jirgas, Panchayats, and the Sardari-cum-feudal network
C) The religious popular expressions as in the Formal Legal Framework
D) The religion in the informal but expressly prevailing environment
These are explored in the ensuing pages in a separate discussion s based upon the structure and foundation of the legal environment from adoption to its implementation.
They are tackled in a systematic and coherent manner with reference to the International Bill of Human Rights and the attached and fundamental documents and treaties attached to the Human Rights Bill.
The major trends of the legal thought and practical application are dealt separately hereby and discussed;
1. The Colonial Legacy
2. The Authoritarian Law Making
3. The Democratic Law Making / the Parliament
4. The religious orthodoxy
5. The Cultural customs and traditions
1. The Colonial Legacy
As mentioned earlier the carving out of the state of Pakisatn is the result of legal process by the conferment of the right of self Government by the Queen of UK in 1947 through the 3 June Plan.
The adoption of 1935 Indian Act as the law of land in the first meeting of the Constituent Assembly was the turning point of the Pakistan’s legal history. This adoption was to be the temporary arrangement till the new Constitution for the Republic was to be adopted, but the ensuing legal complexities were to linger on till the present day. the adoption was not only at the constitutional level but it was at the lower most level in the form of adoption all the British legal instruments with the change of the Name India with Pakisatn usually.
This resulted in the aberration of the legal system which plagues the legal scenario till now. The purpose of the legal system of the British Empire was to protect and sustain the “Steel Frame “ of the British Raj over the Indians. But this steel frame was to be as it is for the post-colonial society in the form of legal environment. The efforts were never aimed at the liberalization, rationalization and the humanization of the legal system of the Pakisatn in the last 6 decades of post-colonial period of existence. The polity of Pakisatn was to be ambivalent, complex, and mercurial and anti-people as the successive changes in the legal framework showed.
The structural construction of the governing framework in the Colonial era was based on the following assertions;
1. The natives were unable to govern themselves; they needed benign rule of the British to make them capable to run self governments.
2. The pre-colonial legal system and structure was inadequate to adjust to the needs and exigencies of the British system so drastically changed the legal framework and environment of the India.
3. The Mughal System of legal administration was enshrined in the local traditions and the cultural mores of the natives and local p[populace. The new legal system was aimed t introduction of the Anglo-Saxon traditions of legal system in the alien land where the natives were the subject of this undue experimentation. The result was the introduction of an elaborate and bureaucratic structure which was ruthless in detail and prompt in its application.
4. The crime regulation system was completely new to the local environment. The introduction of prisons and the police system was entirely alien to the Indian soil. The introduction of this Police system was a severe blow to the human freedom. The Criminal Procedure Code of 1898 was the Steel Frame of this gigantic experiment to control the native “mischievous behavior”!
5. The local revenue system was changed by the introduction of individualized payment system in the form of currency or the individual payment of land revenue instead of the collective payment system for the villages and the specified area.
6. The introduction of the property of the land to the illegal and new occupants after the Permanent Settlement of 1979 in Bengal by Lord Cornelius.
7. The priority of law and order in the crimes control system instead of dealing them in their real perspective.
8. The complete disregard and participation of the local people in the process of legislation for the natives.
9. The discrimination vis-a-vis the natives and Europeans in the application, implementation of the legal system.
10. The sustained policy of exacerbating the urban rural divide in the country due to political exigencies .The treaties made by the local rulers with the British show this anomaly in its overall brutality and harshness towards local people.
2.The Authoritarian Law Making
The legacy of the authoritarian ism bequeathed by the British was carried on the avid followers of the Colonial Masters. They adopted the legal process of the British in the same spirit to keep their hold intact over the local people. This tradition was strengthened by the Military Dictatorships to prolong its rule. The decade of 1960,s, 1980,s are the most prominent in this regard. The specific characteristics of these are as following;
1. the aim of the regimes is to broaden their hold over the segments of the society through the legal means
2. the overall purpose of the law making is the sanctioning the individualistic and dictatorial tendencies of the Dictator
3. The bureaucratic structure of the state is more active and the colonial legacy of the law making is maintained and nurtured further.
4. The support of the regime is limited to certain sections of the society which makes it prone to creating legal immunities sot the supporters of the regime.
5. The resources of the regime are diverted to the areas and strata of the society which help the regime. For this the inherent contradictions are developed in the legal framework of the country which is biased, manipulated by executive and undermine he liberty of the Judiciary. This is corroborated by the earlier legal history of Pakisatn.
6. A pseudo ideological garb of ideology is woven around the legal framework of the country which creates secretiveness and mystery around the legal environment. The challenges to the legal discussions are dealt under the threat to the ideology of the country which changes with the change in the ruler. (The Ayub Era and Zia Era are the true examples).
7. The structural bias of colonial legal framework is skewed further to control dissent, free idea and difference of opinion under the State security ideology. The introduction of the Article 63 in the Constitution by Zia regime is case in point.
8. The absence of the parliament sans the debate and healthy exchange of the ideas on the proposed laws in the dictatorial regimes which stifles the growth of the respect for the human rights and the freedom of the ideas.
9. The increased legislation further extends, enhances the power of colonial inherited institutions of brutality. this phenomenon results in more abuse and repressive towards masses, instead of relief to the people. ( The fine examples of this are the Huddood and Prohibition Ordinances of Zia regime)
10. The implementing arm of the Government i.e. police and attached institutions are protected and given extra powers which curtail the freedom of the people in a complex and sustained way. ( This becomes more horrible and expressive in the semi-urban and rural areas of the country as there is little awareness and literacy to demand its rights)
11. The economic resources are used as a ploy to patronize the sections of the government which adhere to the policies of the Government . The Export Bonus Voucher Scheme of Ayub era is an example of such state patronage.
The dictatorial regimes stress on the obedience and absolute authority which enhances the powers of the powers of the colonially inherited institutions. the dictatorial regime s face a great dilemma as they take over on the promises of changing the destiny of people against the plundering of resources by the inept and corrupt politicians as asserted by them; but the state apparatus which is structurally flawed contributes to its undoing at the end.
The efforts to create unity and discipline through legal means fail to deliver; rather they encourage the separatist and secessionist tendencies. Its examples are the separation of East Pakisatn, the unrest in 1970,s in Baluchistan, in Sindh in 1980,s. This situation deteriorates further when the alien elements are involved; the case of Wazirastan is prime example of this fact.
3. The Democratic /Parliamentary Law Making
Along with the authoritarian regimes the legal developments in the country are result of the democratic law making through the parliament. The traits of this legislation are as following
1. The structure of the Parliament is the determining factor in adoption of the laws. As the structural constitution of the parliament determines the course of the legislation.
2. The leanings of the ruling party or the group of parties are the leading forces which shape up the law making in the Pakistani system.
3. The real legislation of the democratic governments is also dependent upon the same institutions and the legal structure as inherited at the time of independence from the British elite. Their stress is not on changing or transforming the fundamental structure of the legal dispensation at all. Because they are more concerned ot turn the balance of power in the favor of the elected governments as the legislative history of 1990,s shows. This is the settlement of political question through means of legislation within the available parameters and transforming the question of the power between President and the Prime Minister usually. ( The 13 the amendment ) This limitation of the or the locking in of the political governments reduce the scope of action and range of their power to mere structural control instead of creating true legal change in the lives of the people.
4. The inherent political instability and ambiguity of the legal system inherited from the British is increased by every attempt at the change or modification of the existing laws. This is shown by the legislative establishment of newer courts for settling with the increased violence in the society. The establishment of the Anti-terrorist courts shows the inadequacy of the traditional capacity of the courts and the desire of the politicians to improve the law and order system of the country.
5. The biases of the ruling governments as to its electoral base also affect the legislation which helps to perpetuate the rule of few. This further alienates the masses from the social process of development and progress.
6. The institutional capacity of the units of the systems is inadequate to cope with the demands of the modern Human Rights Perspective. The resulting legislation is ambivalent to the rights of people in the practicality.
7. The political uncertainty attached
Bibliography
1. Holy Quran
2. The Constitution Of Islamic Republic Of Pakisatn
3. The Major Acts
4. The Minor Acts
5. The Making Of Pakistan By Richard Symonds
6. Emergence Of Pakisatn By Chaudhery Muhammad Ali
7. The Manual of Prisons Law
8. The Manual of Land Revenue Laws
9. Human Rights--- A Compilation of International Instruments Volume I & II Published by United Nations 2004
10. Human Development in South Asia Published by Mahbub-ul-Haq Development Center Islamabad. ( Various Reports)
11. World Development Report Published By World Bank ( Various Reports)
12. Constitutional Development in Pakistan By G.W Chaudhery
13. Liberty or Death? By Patrick French
Magazines, Newspapers
1. The Monthly Herald Karachi.
2. The Monthly News line Karachi.
3. Daily Dawn Islamabad. Lahore. Karachi Editions
4. Daily Nation Lahore.
5. Daily News Lahore. Rawalpindi Karachi
6. Daily Times Lahore.
7. Daily Nawa-i- Waqt Lahore / Rawalpindi .
8. Daily Jang Lahore /Islamabad
9. Pakisatn Law Digest P.L.D ( Various Issues)
10. Daily Khabrain Lahore.
Note . This article was written in year 2005 and was submitted to UN Human Rights Council via the course I attended in FSA Islamabad. Basic premises of the article are same and as to changes during the time passed I will write later...Insha Allah!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
رات
رات لمبی اور آگ برستی...
-
Modernity, Islam ...Role of Political Interpretation as a Power Tool . Islam has a wonderful and amazingly rich cultural traditions and...
-
Sky is the epitome of looking towards creator and it has different connotations and meaning in varying contexts. From fancy of imagination t...
-
Shiv Kumar Batalvi, What an amazing person and poetry. The whole Punjab dances in his words. The Chenab and Jehlum are cystals of rain...